
A spoiler-light review of Rian Johnson’s third Benoit Blanc mystery. The premise and the victim are discussed, but the solution is not.
A Church That Feels Like a Crime Scene
An old stone church ought to offer a certain reassurance. Even if you are not particularly religious, there is something familiar about the rows of pews, the worn timber and the coloured light moving across the floor. In Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery, Rian Johnson uses all of that familiarity against us. The building is imposing, the congregation is small, and the people who keep coming back seem less comforted by their faith than trapped inside somebody else’s version of it.

This is the third outing for Benoit Blanc, although Daniel Craig’s detective takes his time arriving. We begin instead with Father Jud Duplenticy, a young priest with a boxing past, a difficult temper and a fairly straightforward idea of what his calling is supposed to mean. Josh O’Connor plays him without the saintly glow that films often give to supposedly good people. Jud can be angry and awkward, and he occasionally makes things worse by trying too hard to put them right.

The shift from Glass Onion is immediately apparent. Gone are the sun, the expensive toys and the rather pleased-with-itself wealth of that island. Here, Blanc has been called to a parish in upstate New York, and the tone leans towards Gothic mystery without forgetting that there is still a murder to solve. I liked that change of scenery, partly because Johnson does not seem interested in making the same film three times. Even the air in this one feels colder.


Father Jud Is the Film’s Real Centre
Jud has been transferred to Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude after punching a deacon, an introduction that tells us rather more about him than a tidy speech about compassion would. He believes people deserve kindness, yet he is not always good at handling people who refuse to offer any back. The contradiction gives O’Connor room to play a priest who is sincere without being simple, and it makes him an unusually useful companion for a detective who distrusts anything he cannot explain.


I kept returning to O’Connor’s face during the quieter exchanges. He listens closely, sometimes with the expression of someone trying to prevent his own patience from running out, and his frustration never feels like an actor announcing a big emotional moment. There is a history behind Jud’s gentleness, and the film allows that history to complicate him. He is not good because he has never done anything wrong; he is trying to be good because he knows perfectly well what going wrong feels like.

One scene involving a telephone conversation with Louise, a worker who may have information relevant to the case, says more about Jud than another ten minutes of exposition could have done. What begins as a faintly comic interruption turns into an unexpected request for comfort, and Jud has to decide where his attention belongs. It is one of the film’s better choices to let that conversation breathe. For a while the crime can wait, which is rather the point.


There is an obvious temptation to call this O’Connor’s film rather than Craig’s, but the two performances work because they are asking different questions. Blanc wants an account of events that can survive scrutiny, while Jud wants to know what a decent person should do when the facts offer no comfort. Their partnership develops through disagreement as much as affection. That is much more interesting than simply putting an eccentric detective beside a helpful sidekick.

The Man at the Pulpit
Monsignor Jefferson Wicks, played by Josh Brolin, runs the parish as if it were a personal kingdom under permanent siege. His sermons are forceful, his certainties plentiful and his interpretation of charity remarkably selective. I can understand why some parishioners might mistake that sort of conviction for leadership, particularly when the alternative involves admitting how lonely or frightened they are. Johnson is less interested in portraying a cartoon villain than in showing how authority can become a habit nobody questions.


Brolin gives Wicks the necessary theatricality without making him entirely unbelievable. He looks at the congregation as though every reaction belongs to him, and a rebuke can be delivered with the same confidence as a blessing. Standing near him, Jud looks increasingly uncomfortable with the whole arrangement. Their disagreements are not really about doctrine; they are about whether faith should make people less afraid of one another or give somebody another reason to frighten them.

The atmosphere is fertile ground for a murder mystery because almost everyone appears to have a reason to resent Wicks, even if they are unwilling to say so out loud. The congregation’s loyalty is real, but so are its private grievances, humiliations and unfinished bargains. When the monsignor is killed during a Good Friday service, the crime feels like the inevitable explosion of tensions that have been allowed to accumulate for years. The seemingly impossible method is another matter entirely.


A Very Peculiar Congregation
Glenn Close is particularly good as Martha Delacroix, a woman whose attachment to the church is practically part of its architecture. She tends to its business, preserves its traditions and carries herself with the air of somebody who has already judged your behaviour before you have spoken. Close allows a little absurdity into the performance without losing the harder emotions underneath. Martha can be funny, unsettling and unexpectedly vulnerable, sometimes within the same exchange.

Around her, Johnson assembles the sort of group in which every character looks as though they have wandered in from a different film. Kerry Washington’s Vera Draven is a lawyer carrying responsibilities that seem to have narrowed her life; Daryl McCormack plays Cy Draven, whose political ambitions have been transformed by the appetite for online attention. Andrew Scott’s Lee Ross is a writer with bruised professional pride and opinions that seem to become more elaborate the less anyone listens.


Jeremy Renner plays the troubled doctor Nat Sharp, while Cailee Spaeny’s Simone Vivane and Thomas Haden Church’s groundskeeper Samson Holt bring their own silences and private histories to the parish. Mila Kunis, as police chief Geraldine Scott, supplies a welcome sense of practical impatience with a case that refuses to behave like an ordinary investigation. There are times when I wanted a little more from several of these people, but the crowded cast also helps the church feel like a genuine social ecosystem.

That is what the best ensemble mysteries understand. A suspect is not simply a name to be crossed off a list; there ought to be enough life around them that their decisions make sense even if they turn out to be innocent. Wake Up Dead Man does not always achieve that balance. Still, it gives its supporting players enough particular habits and resentments to make their shared loyalty to Wicks look stranger the longer we watch them.


A Properly Impossible Murder
Johnson has spoken about his fondness for the impossible-crime tradition, and this case has the right old-fashioned appeal. The murder takes place in a small room beside the church pulpit during a service, with the apparent circumstances leaving no straightforward explanation for how it could have happened. The puzzle recalls the locked-room stories associated with John Dickson Carr, where the pleasure lies in testing every assumption about space, timing and what witnesses believe they saw.

There is a satisfying difference between a story that conceals information and one that encourages you to look at available information the wrong way. Johnson mostly plays the second game here. We watch people react to events, accept their explanations and slowly realise that our confidence may be based on very little. I enjoyed following the logic even when I suspected the film was arranging the furniture in my head, figuratively speaking, while I was looking elsewhere.


I will leave the actual solution alone, because taking apart a murder mystery before somebody has watched it seems a poor use of a review. What matters is that the eventual explanation is connected to the film’s ideas about loyalty, guilt and self-preservation rather than appearing as a mechanical trick for its own sake. A few turns ask for patience, and the last act has plenty to explain, but the architecture of the mystery remains worth the effort.

Johnson Still Remembers the Jokes
Despite the stonework, the religious imagery and the generally miserable weather, the film has not forgotten its sense of humour. Blanc’s elaborate way of speaking remains a pleasure, especially when it collides with Geraldine’s much more economical approach to policing. The comedy works best when it exposes a person’s vanity or punctures the solemnity of the situation. It is noticeably less interested in asking everyone to be funny all the time.

The references to popular culture are often sharper than they first appear. Cy’s understanding of Star Wars, for instance, says a great deal about the ease with which people can cast themselves as the heroic rebellion while borrowing the language of its villains. Johnson directed The Last Jedi, of course, but the joke does not need a theory about his feelings towards fandom to land. It works because the character gives himself away almost without noticing.


There is also a pleasure in watching Johnson shift register so abruptly: a sinister corridor gives way to a ridiculous exchange, then to a conversation unexpectedly full of regret. Not every shift is graceful, and I occasionally felt the film was working through more ideas than it could comfortably carry. Yet the changes of tone make the people feel less like pieces on a detective’s board. Even the guilty and the self-important have moments when they are simply rather foolish.

Faith, Doubt and the Uses of Power
The question running beneath the mystery is not whether faith itself is good or bad. It is what people choose to do with their beliefs once they have an audience, a position of authority or somebody else’s trust. Wicks seems to require enemies in order to keep his congregation close. Jud, by contrast, is drawn towards people who need help even when helping them offers him no advantage. The distinction is plain enough, but the film finds emotional complications within it.

Blanc brings a different kind of conviction into the church. He trusts evidence, reason and the possibility that a contradiction can eventually be resolved if you stay with it long enough. The case forces him to work alongside a man for whom not every important question has that kind of answer. I appreciated that Johnson does not ask either character to abandon his worldview merely so the film can deliver a neat speech about tolerance.

Martha provides another variation on the same subject. Her devotion is deeply entangled with memory, reputation and the institution that has shaped her life. Close makes it possible to understand why somebody would protect a place long after it stopped protecting the people inside it. This is where the film becomes more troubling than a conventional puzzle: a murder may have an identifiable culprit, while an unhealthy system can have many willing participants.


The scene with Louise is worth remembering in this context. There is no congregation to impress, no pulpit and no prospect of winning an argument; there is only a stranger asking for a little time. It suggests that faith is most convincing here when nobody is performing it. For all its Gothic excess, Wake Up Dead Man is unexpectedly interested in that modest, undramatic act of being present for another person.

The Pleasure of Watching a Film Look Like Something
Cinematographer Steve Yedlin and production designer Rick Heinrichs make the church a space you can almost navigate from memory. The architecture has weight, the corridors seem capable of hiding whole histories, and patches of coloured light are never quite enough to relieve the darkness. It is a handsome film, though not in the glossy, expensive-holiday sense of Glass Onion. Its beauty is colder, more severe and more suited to people whose secrets have become part of the building.

Nathan Johnson’s score works with the religious setting without turning every scene into a warning from the heavens. Bob Ducsay’s editing, meanwhile, has the less conspicuous job of keeping an increasingly intricate case intelligible. A film with this many people, motives and shifts in perspective could quickly become exhausting. There were moments when I wished the pace would tighten, but I never felt that I had lost track of the basic human stakes.

At roughly two hours and twenty-five minutes, it is a long evening in the pews. Some characters deserve more time, while one or two explanations might have been delivered with a lighter touch. That said, I would rather watch a mystery take the risk of lingering on its characters than see every uncomfortable silence removed in the editing suite. Johnson clearly wants the solution to matter to people, not just to a detective with a notebook.

What Stays After the Case Is Closed
I probably would not reach for Wake Up Dead Man when I wanted the breeziest of the three Blanc films. The original Knives Out remains wonderfully nimble, and Glass Onion has a ridiculous energy that makes it easy to revisit. This one asks for more patience and is occasionally a little too pleased with the scope of its own ideas. It also has something the others did not need to carry: an earnest, sometimes uncomfortable interest in what it means to live according to a belief.

Craig continues to make Blanc enjoyable without letting the mannerisms become the whole performance, but O’Connor gives the film its necessary weight. Jud is neither a flawless moral example nor a conveniently disillusioned sceptic. He is someone trying to practise what he preaches in an environment where preaching has become a means of control. I found that more affecting than the eventual arrangement of suspects, clues and explanations, clever though those are.

By the end I was glad Johnson had taken the series somewhere darker. Not because another mystery needed more misery, but because a church full of frightened people provides a different sort of challenge for Benoit Blanc. The detective can explain how somebody died; the film is interested in what everyone else does with that knowledge. When the noise of the last reveal has passed, that quieter question is the one that stays with me.

Film details and further reading: Netflix Tudum’s production and cast guide and its account of the film’s Gothic visual approach. Film frame selections are from Scene Still; production stills are credited individually in their captions. All images remain the property of their respective rights holders.
Leave a Reply