
There was a time when a serial-killer thriller could earn its place on the video-store shelf with little more than a nasty title, a striking cover and a promise that somebody would have a very bad night. I remember the sort of films that lived between the big releases: not quite prestige pictures, not quite bargain-bin rubbish, and frequently watched far too late because returning the tape was tomorrow’s problem. Psycho Killer (2026) brought that whole neglected corner of cinema back to mind. I’m not entirely sure it meant to.
Andrew Kevin Walker’s screenplay, Gavin Polone’s direction and Georgina Campbell in the lead ought to make for an intriguing combination. Instead, the film wanders from grief-stricken police pursuit to occult nightmare and eventually into something that resembles an end-of-the-world demonstration staged inside a power station. It is untidy, sometimes unintentionally funny and not especially convincing. Yet its older, rougher instincts held my attention longer than I expected.

A film that arrived twenty years late
The film has an unusually long history. Walker, whose Se7en helped turn the serial murderer into a near-mythic screen figure, wrote Psycho Killer years before it finally reached cinemas in February 2026. Directors and production plans came and went; Polone, better known as a producer, eventually made it his feature directing debut. Knowing that history explains some of the displacement I felt while watching. This is not a contemporary horror film pretending to be a throwback. It is, in a sense, an older idea that survived long enough to find itself in a different era.
The story starts simply enough. Kansas highway patrol officer Jane Archer watches her husband become another victim of a masked murderer nicknamed the Satanic Slasher. Her pursuit takes her across a landscape of cold roads, tired buildings and uncomfortable encounters, while the killer moves steadily towards a much larger plan. That basic structure belongs to a lineage of films in which the American road is both escape route and trap. The trouble is that the film keeps asking its modest pursuit narrative to carry more weight than it can bear.
I expected the pedigree to yield something more controlled. Se7en had the confidence to let a city, its weather and its moral exhaustion do much of the storytelling. Psycho Killer reaches for a similarly rotten atmosphere, but its pieces often seem to belong to different films. The police procedural, satanic conspiracy and revenge story do not so much blend as take turns at the wheel.
Georgina Campbell, doing the difficult work
Campbell is the clearest reason to stay with it. Jane could have been written as a standard revenge protagonist, an officer who gets a tragic motivation and then spends the remainder of the film proving she is tougher than everyone else. Campbell finds a quieter register. Her Jane is alert but worn down, pushing ahead because stopping would mean having to face the loss that started the journey. She plays the increasingly extravagant circumstances with complete seriousness, and that seriousness gives the film a centre.

It is not a faultless character. Much of Jane’s interior life is suggested rather than explored, and the film introduces a late personal revelation without allowing it the emotional space it deserves. But Campbell does not try to disguise those shortcomings with excessive performance. A glance, a pause, the slightly delayed response to something horrible: often these do more for the film than another piece of explanatory dialogue.

There is something almost reassuring about a genre actor refusing to wink at the audience. Modern horror can be so anxious about acknowledging its own conventions that sincerity begins to look like a risky choice. Campbell simply commits to the material. When the rest of the film starts to wobble, she remains the person you can believe.
A killer who is less a person than a warning sign
James Preston Rogers plays the masked murderer, Richard Joshua Reeves, with an intentionally excessive physicality. The mask, the compulsive movement and the almost ritualistic approach to violence make him feel less like an identifiable criminal than a problem the countryside has somehow produced. There are echoes here of The Hitcher and the grubbier side of late-twentieth-century exploitation, where explanation often mattered less than the knowledge that something terrible was coming down the road.

What the film cannot decide is what Reeves represents. Is he a man whose belief system has become monstrous, a symbolic embodiment of religious panic, or simply a cinematic monster with access to a car and a spectacularly unhealthy routine? A little uncertainty could have served the story. Instead, the film alternates between treating him as a character and treating him as an instrument for whatever escalation is required next. He remains an unsettling presence, but rarely becomes an interesting one.
That is also where Walker’s reputation works against the film. His strongest writing gives depravity an unsettling logic without necessarily asking us to admire it. Here, the occult vocabulary accumulates faster than the meaning. Symbols and speeches announce how extreme everything is becoming, while the human stakes grow harder to see.
The best part is the landscape
What I liked most was not the mythology. It was the feeling of being somewhere in the middle of America, far from anyone likely to help. Empty roads, weak motel lighting, fields stretched flat under a pale sky, buildings that seem to exist only for people passing through: the locations do a surprising amount of work. They return the film to the ordinary anxieties that made so many older thrillers effective. The unsettling thought is not just that somebody dangerous is nearby. It is that the next town might be no different.

Production designer Roger Fires has described the visual scheme as a deliberate opposition. Jane’s world begins in cooler tones, closer to blue; Reeves inhabits warmer colours that move towards an infernal red. As the pursuit closes the distance between them, those visual worlds converge. It is a more considered idea than the screenplay sometimes allows you to notice. Even the roadside interiors were frequently constructed rather than found, designed to resemble the unremarkable American spaces in which the story might plausibly occur.
Fires has also explained how several motel interiors were built as modular sets, with walls, corridors and entrances rearranged to create different spaces. Pendleton’s house and the power-station control room were substantially built for the production. That labour matters, particularly in a film whose best moments depend on a sense of physical environment. The road may be an old horror cliché, but the small details make it feel lived in rather than pulled from a digital catalogue.

Malcolm McDowell enters a different film
Then Malcolm McDowell appears as Mr Pendleton, surrounded by wealth, eccentricity and satanic decoration. He does not have to do much to establish the tone of this detour. His presence carries decades of cult-film associations, and the interiors seem to have been built to accommodate every last one. It is an odd stretch of the film: theatrical, rather silly, and somehow more honest about its absurdity than much of what surrounds it.

I enjoyed the peculiar density of Pendleton’s home, even when I was less persuaded by what the story wanted from him. The furniture, pictures, fabrics and accumulated objects suggest a life that has grown increasingly enclosed by its own mythology. It is a room-by-room portrait of someone with too much money and too few sensible people willing to tell him to stop decorating.

The final act misses the exit
From this point on, discussing the film means giving away where its journey ends. The modest revenge thriller expands towards an apocalyptic plot centred on a nuclear facility, and the gulf between its original premise and its ambitions becomes almost comical. A deranged religious plan is one thing; expecting it to provide a satisfying conclusion to Jane’s grief is another. The film has not done enough connective work to make the transition feel earned.

And yet I cannot say the escalation bored me. The industrial setting is convincing, the visual staging has a certain reckless grandeur, and the killer’s theatricality finally finds a space large enough to contain it. There is a difference, though, between an ending that becomes gloriously ridiculous and one that simply loses its grip on the people who were supposed to matter. Psycho Killer occupies an awkward position between the two.

The final confrontation also exposes how little the film has clarified its ideas about faith, violence, grief and revenge. They remain motifs rather than arguments. Its loudest moments are memorable as images, but those images do not settle the questions raised by the quieter first half. The ending feels designed to outgrow the story, and succeeds rather too well.
A relic from the serial-killer years
Part of my interest in the film comes from the period it appears to have escaped. For those of us who encountered Se7en, Copycat, Resurrection and a succession of lesser imitators through cinemas, television and video rental, the serial-killer thriller became a recognisable product. Rain, notebooks, religious symbolism, disturbed detectives and carefully theatrical murders appeared so regularly that the formula became its own visual language.
That language has not disappeared. True-crime documentaries, podcasts and streaming series have simply altered the way we consume stories about murder. The old fictional killer was a grotesque device for exploring fear and moral exhaustion. Today, viewers are more likely to recognise the uncomfortable relationship between such entertainment and the real lives it borrows from. Psycho Killer seems relatively uninterested in that conversation. It believes in its villain as an uncomplicated force of evil, and in the old genre machinery as a perfectly reasonable way to tell a story.
I do not think nostalgia excuses its failures. The occasional sense of having discovered a forgotten VHS release is entertaining, but it cannot supply structure or character development on its own. Still, I find something revealing about a film that has arrived so late that its storytelling conventions have become historical artefacts. Its imperfections are not necessarily charming; they are interesting evidence of what the genre used to tolerate, and sometimes even celebrate.
What survives after the credits
Psycho Killer is not a hidden masterpiece, and I would struggle to recommend it without several qualifications. Campbell deserves a more coherent film, and the pacing and tonal shifts repeatedly weaken the tension. Rogers supplies a distinctive physical threat, but the writing never quite makes him more than the sum of his grotesque habits. Walker’s name promises a sharper examination of evil than the story ultimately delivers.
What remains is the strange persistence of a certain kind of movie. I liked the frozen roads, the motel interiors, the exhausted determination of its lead, and the slightly embarrassing freedom with which it finally loses its head. I can imagine it being rediscovered years from now by somebody browsing through an endless streaming catalogue, long after the promotional campaign has vanished. That does not make it better. It merely means the film has the kind of awkward character that can survive a disappointing first impression.
I finished it unconvinced but not entirely indifferent. Some films leave you thinking about what they were trying to say. This one left me thinking about where it had come from, and how far the genre had travelled while it was stuck getting made.
Further reading: Roger Fires on the film’s production design, and the official film page.
Leave a Reply