
A battered videotape used to be enough to give a film a reputation. A lurid sleeve, a rumour about it being banned, and somebody insisting that the footage was real could keep the story going for years. You did not even have to see the film. Half the entertainment was the whispered description from somebody who claimed to have watched it in a friend’s living room, usually after everyone else had gone to bed.
That was the peculiar territory occupied by 1978’s Faces of Death. Its mythology travelled farther than the truth, and its mixture of staged sequences and genuine footage left people arguing over which was which. Watching Daniel Goldhaber’s 2026 reimagining, I kept coming back to the distance between that analogue dare and today’s feed. The old film invited you to seek something forbidden. The new one takes place in a world where the forbidden has a recommendation engine, a comments section and, somewhere behind the scenes, a poor sod paid to review it.
I went into this expecting a contemporary horror remake trading on an infamous title. Instead I found a film with a surprisingly sound reason to exist, even when its later scenes settle for more familiar slasher territory. Its central question is no longer simply whether the disturbing image is real. It is what happens to that image, and to us, once the internet has finished with it.
The tape you had to find

Faces of Death first appeared in 1978 as a pseudo-documentary presented through the language of serious inquiry. What viewers encountered was an uncomfortable patchwork: actual material, staged incidents, exploitation-film sensationalism and narration that encouraged you to treat the whole thing as a grim factual record. Its reputation grew in the home-video years, when the notion that a tape was difficult to find could be more persuasive than anything printed on its sleeve. A claim that something had been banned was sometimes all the advertising it needed.
There was effort involved in seeking out those films. Someone knew a shop or had a dubious copy; someone else had a television and a player; everybody brought their own nervous curiosity. I do not think that made viewers more virtuous, but there was at least a decision to be made. You had to put a tape into a machine. Today’s equivalent can arrive between a recipe, a pet video and a spectacularly bad opinion about something you never asked to discuss.
Goldhaber and co-writer Isa Mazzei make an intelligent choice by keeping the 1978 film inside the story as a real cultural artefact. This is not a straightforward reconstruction of its grisly episodes. It is a film about the afterlife of that film: what happens when somebody grows up with its notoriety and mistakes its methods for a creative template. The old question of authenticity survives, but the environment around it is almost unrecognisable.
Margot: the woman paid to look

Barbie Ferreira plays Margot Romero, a moderator at Kino, a video platform that looks familiar enough without needing a real company’s logo. Her working day is a succession of uploaded clips and decisions about what the public should be allowed to see. It is a rather ingenious setting for horror: rows of desks, fluorescent lighting, policy categories and people expected to become accustomed to things nobody should have to watch for a living. The spectacle has already happened by the time it reaches her screen. All that remains is to decide which button to press.
Margot’s personal life makes that work more complicated. She carries the aftermath of a family tragedy that became viral material, leaving her both painfully aware of how an image can escape its context and increasingly desperate to control what happens next. Ferreira gives the character a guarded, brittle quality that I liked. She is not presented as a spotless heroine or a detective who effortlessly spots what everyone else misses. She is uneasy with people, not always careful, and often driven as much by guilt as by conviction.
When Margot begins noticing uploads that resemble scenes from the original Faces of Death, the uncertainty feels entirely credible. Are these ingenious re-creations, tasteless entertainment or documentation of something much worse? At first she tries to assess them through the ordinary rules of her job. That is one of the film’s more disturbing ideas: human suffering has been converted into a professional classification problem, and the person most qualified to recognise trouble is the one the system has trained to keep processing.

The supporting players help establish the atmosphere without turning every colleague into a villain. Jermaine Fowler’s Josh is a manager concerned with keeping the operation moving; Charli XCX’s Gabby embodies a more casually jaded response to what appears on screen. Around them is a workplace whose cheery claims about protection sit rather awkwardly beside its dependence on constant viewing. The organisation is not interested in philosophical uncertainty. It has targets to meet, and terrible things are just another category of material to process.
When being viral means nobody believes you

One detail that gives the film an emotional edge is Margot’s damaged credibility. She has already been made into an internet story against her will, and people who remember the incident think they know who she is. It is a nasty little irony: being seen by thousands of strangers does not make you understood by any of them. When she starts raising alarms about the footage, those around her have a convenient explanation for her behaviour. She is obsessing again. She is making things personal. Perhaps the evidence is real, but her reputation has arrived first.
Her roommate Ryan, played by Aaron Holliday, offers a different perspective. He knows the lore surrounding old horror films and helps explain the original Faces of Death without turning the scene into a history lecture. That is important because the film is asking two generations of media to speak to each other. Ryan knows what an infamous tape used to mean. Margot knows what happens to footage after an upload. Neither kind of knowledge is enough by itself to make the situation safe.
I found this side of the story more compelling than the mystery of who is producing the videos. The internet allows a person’s worst day to become an endlessly available public record, and Margot understands that in a way most investigators in horror films do not. She is trying to work out whether the new footage records real harm while living with the fact that an old recording has already defined her. The detective story and the personal damage are bound together, which makes the investigation feel less like a hobby and more like something she cannot leave alone.
Arthur and the horror of the content creator

Dacre Montgomery’s Arthur Spevak is an appropriately unpleasant bridge between the two films. He approaches the original as an aspiring creator might approach a piece of established intellectual property: identify the recognisable moments, recreate the material, and package the result for circulation. He is part obsessive fan, part failed auteur and part attention-hungry opportunist. What makes him contemporary is not merely that he uses technology, but that he understands how people behave once the footage starts moving between screens.
The old film’s supposed authenticity becomes his selling point. He knows that viewers will watch, argue, dismiss the footage as fake, share it to ask for opinions and perhaps reward him with exactly the audience he wants. The question of who is responsible for spreading the material becomes harder to answer once each person has a plausible excuse. One is investigating. Another is debunking. A third is merely passing it along. Meanwhile the numbers go up, and Arthur mistakes circulation for significance.
Montgomery plays him as a man who has given his obsession the dignity of a project. There is an ugly comedy in that sort of self-importance, especially when the film draws attention to the logic of remakes themselves. Arthur is recycling an infamous property for visibility, just as the film is making use of a notorious title to get us into the cinema. It knows the contradiction is there. The question is how much the audience enjoys recognising it before wanting another set piece.
The remake that knows where the money comes from

Goldhaber and Mazzei are well suited to the material. Their earlier collaboration, Cam, already looked at the instability of online identity and the unease of seeing a version of yourself circulate beyond your control. In a Los Angeles Times interview, Goldhaber also recalled his own experience working in content moderation. That gives this new film a connection to contemporary digital labour which feels more substantial than simply placing a killer on a social-media app.
For much of its running time, Faces of Death uses that premise well. The screens do not need to be supernatural or cursed; the policies governing them can be arbitrary, and the people behind them can be exhausted, indifferent or sincerely trying to help. There are moments when the system feels more frightening than the person exploiting it. The film is clever enough to see the corporate absurdity in this, without pretending that a more carefully worded moderation policy would put an end to our appetite for spectacle.
Then the film shifts into familiar horror mechanics. The later movement towards pursuit, captivity and confrontation is tense enough, but it reduces a diffuse, unnerving problem to something we can recognise as a slasher plot. I did not mind the change in the moment. There is room in horror for a physical struggle and a bit of grubby genre business. I just found myself missing the colder film about a woman trying to make sense of what her workplace had taught her to ignore. Once Arthur becomes the whole problem, the larger machine gets to fade into the background.
The uncomfortable business of watching

A new film bearing the Faces of Death name is inevitably going to be judged on its appetite for gore. This one does not sidestep the expectation, and there is a strain of very physical horror in its more confrontational scenes. Yet I think the stronger discomfort comes earlier, when the film leaves us with a screen and a decision about what to do with what we have seen. An ugly image can be shocking. An environment in which thousands of people are encouraged to watch, categorise, argue and move on is unsettling in a different way.
That is also where the film’s own hypocrisy becomes most interesting. It wants to question the pleasure we take in looking, but it depends on attracting our attention to the very material it questions. I do not expect horror to be morally spotless; the genre would have a rather empty history if that were the entry requirement. The more revealing test is whether the film does anything with the contradiction beyond pointing it out. Here it manages enough to be worth watching, even if some conversations underline an idea that the images had already made perfectly clear.
There is a useful distinction between shock and disturbance, and the film is better at the latter. When something shocking passes through a feed, the reaction can be immediate but short-lived. Disturbance hangs around after the screen has been switched off. The scenes I remember are not necessarily the most elaborate or violent ones. They are the ordinary moments when Margot wonders whether anybody is listening, while the site continues doing precisely what it was built to do.
The internet gets the last word

The final stretch brings the story back to the machinery of uploading and reaction. Margot may establish what happened, but evidence does not necessarily produce understanding. It becomes another thing to circulate, another item for viewers to weigh up, another opportunity to make a joke. The ending is bleak without needing to insist that every person online has lost their humanity. There are people who care; they are simply working within a system that makes indifference very easy and attention very profitable.
For all my reservations, I found Faces of Death a more thoughtful use of an old horror property than I expected. Ferreira gives its anxious centre some credibility, Montgomery makes an unpleasantly convincing modern obsessive, and Goldhaber and Mazzei find a genuine connection between an infamous videotape and a world overflowing with images. I would have preferred the film to stay with its more corrosive ideas for longer rather than heading quite so confidently towards a conventional showdown, but I appreciated that there were ideas to lose in the first place.
The original Faces of Death depended on the possibility that the forbidden footage might be genuine. The 2026 film lives with a harsher problem: even when something is genuine, the audience may greet it with scepticism, fatigue or a joke typed before the video has finished. That shift has happened quietly enough that we barely notice it anymore. The film notices, even if it cannot resist offering another spectacle of its own.
Leave a Reply