
There is a particular sort of horror film that makes its best argument in the opening ten minutes. An isolated landscape, something old buried beneath it, a cast who can act and a little confidence with the practical effects are usually enough to get me interested. The Morrigan, Colum Eastwood’s 2025 film, has all of those things. Unfortunately, it also has people who keep doing precisely what the screenplay needs them to do, regardless of whether any sensible person would.
That became the problem with my evening watching it. I didn’t mind the small budget, the familiar setup or the occasional visible seam in the effects. What began to wear me down was the growing suspicion that the characters had stopped thinking for themselves. When a film borrows the name of a goddess associated with war, prophecy and fate, I expect something more disturbing than a succession of poor decisions that might have been avoided by a brief conversation.

A promising dig, and a warning nobody wants to hear
The setup is an appealingly old-fashioned piece of folk horror. Fiona Scott, played by Saffron Burrows, is an archaeologist who travels to a remote Irish island in pursuit of an ancient burial site. Her teenage daughter Lily, played by Emily Flain, comes along reluctantly, bringing the sort of resentment that doesn’t suddenly disappear because somebody has booked a boat and called it family time. Fiona can read history better than she can read her own child, which gives the story a human fault line before the supernatural business begins.
At the dig, a sealed casket promises a discovery with enormous implications. The film’s official synopsis takes us from there to a broken seal, the release of the Morrigan, Lily’s possession and a storm that strands everybody on the island. It’s familiar machinery, but I don’t object to familiar machinery when the setting has this much potential. I grew up watching enough horror on video to be perfectly comfortable with a forbidden tomb and a warning that arrives several minutes too late. What matters is whether the film knows how to turn those ingredients into dread.
Initially, it does. The excavation has texture, the landscape feels damp and inhospitable, and the sense of a long-hidden thing resisting modern curiosity makes a good beginning. The camera doesn’t need to do very much when an ordinary head torch can make a hole in the ground look threatening. More importantly, Fiona’s professional ambition ought to make her culpable in a way that goes beyond accidentally releasing the wrong supernatural presence. She has spent years wanting to prove herself; the question is what happens when being right turns out to be the worst possible outcome.

Fiona and Lily: the film’s better story
For me, the most convincing material is the tension between Fiona and Lily. Burrows has a controlled, slightly remote presence that suits a woman accustomed to being taken seriously at work and rather less successful at home. Flain gives Lily an impatience that feels less like melodramatic teenage rebellion than years of being an afterthought. Their early scenes suggest a relationship defined by missed signals, with Fiona trying to make gestures that arrive long after Lily needed them.
Possession should make this uncomfortable situation much worse. A mother who hasn’t listened to her daughter’s anger suddenly has to confront a body and voice she can no longer recognise. There is room here for a story about control, independence and the terrible possibility that someone else has understood your child better than you have. A war goddess taking up residence in a teenage girl could have made Lily’s resentment frightening precisely because there was something recognisable underneath it.
The film gestures towards these ideas, then tends to reduce them to rescue mechanics. Lily becomes a vessel, Fiona must bring her back, and the subtleties of their relationship are repeatedly pushed aside for the next burst of supernatural activity. I wanted the possession to expose things that were already wrong between them, not simply overwrite them. That’s not a demand for a more respectable or intellectual horror film; it is a fairly basic wish that the emotional story and the monster story should be about the same thing.

A capable cast doing the screenplay’s repair work
Burrows gives the film what might otherwise be missing entirely: a dependable centre. She can make Fiona’s guarded manner feel like character rather than a gap in the writing, and she brings a believable seriousness to the archaeological work. When the plot asks Fiona to take another questionable turn, Burrows at least makes the character look as though there might be a reason for it. That is the kind of quiet repair work an experienced actor can do, although it only goes so far.
The supporting cast is equally difficult to fault as an idea. Toby Stephens, James Cosmo, Jonathan Forbes and Art Parkinson bring different kinds of authority or vulnerability to the island. Cosmo in particular has the sort of weathered screen presence that suggests a man who knows the history of a place and has decided not to talk about most of it. I wanted these people to contribute to the island’s sense of collective memory, especially when the mythology begins to intrude on the present.
Instead, too many secondary characters exist to obstruct Fiona, provide information or arrive in danger at the appointed time. Fiona’s professional struggles and the men’s attempts to control the dig hint at a sharper story about authority and the ownership of history, but the film seldom develops these frictions beyond their immediate usefulness. People stop feeling like inhabitants of a place and start feeling like a queue waiting for the next set piece.

The Morrígan is much stranger than a monster in a tomb
The film’s most frustrating missed opportunity is right there in its title. The Morrígan of Irish mythology isn’t simply a scary pagan woman who enjoys killing people. She is associated with battle, fate, prophecy and the terror that can precede death, and appears across traditions in complex, sometimes shifting relationships with figures such as Badb and Macha. Even the stories and groupings differ depending on the source. That instability is part of what makes her interesting: she isn’t easily reduced to one face or one neat explanation.
Eastwood’s film is entitled to reinterpret the mythology. Horror has always borrowed from folklore and rearranged the furniture, sometimes to excellent effect. The disappointment is that the film takes an extraordinary figure and makes her relatively ordinary: an ancient evil imprisoned for centuries, accidentally released, then routed through the familiar conventions of possession and bodily threat. There are glimpses of another film in which the goddess doesn’t merely kill people but seems to know, perhaps even determine, the endings they are moving towards.
If you invoke a figure associated with fate, the choices people make ought to acquire an awful sense of inevitability. Fiona’s ambition, Lily’s anger, the islanders’ old loyalties and the professionals’ arrogance could all have felt like parts of a pattern established long before the excavation began. Instead, they are often separate motivations that the screenplay picks up and puts down. The goddess becomes a source of incidents rather than the force organising the story, which seems a waste of a perfectly good deity.

Folk horror needs more than a remote island
A landscape can do a great deal for horror, especially when it is allowed to feel inhabited rather than merely photogenic. The best folk horror suggests that the past has left practical traces: taboos, rumours, family loyalties, half-forgotten rituals, even the ordinary ways people avoid talking about something unpleasant. The Morrigan has a remote island, ancient remains and a storm. It certainly looks as though it belongs in the genre, but there are stretches where the place feels more like an efficient location than a community with a complicated memory.
That difference matters. If the island had its own competing ideas about the burial site, Fiona’s academic confidence might have become a source of conflict instead of simply a means to open the tomb. The people around her could have had motives rooted in fear, self-interest or inherited guilt rather than a need to delay the protagonists. I kept wanting the island to push back against her interpretation of the past, as if the land itself had a version of events that nobody could quite agree upon.
What emerges is an unusually thin kind of folk horror: the signs are all there, but the social and cultural roots don’t go very deep. The buried goddess is supposed to connect centuries of violence to the present. Too often, though, she functions as a monster who happens to have been in storage for a long time. That’s fine for a straightforward creature feature; it feels rather small for this particular myth.

Practical effects with more conviction than the plotting
I did like that much of the horror seemed to have physical substance. A grimy surface, an altered face or a body moving in an unnatural way can be more persuasive than a beautifully rendered digital apparition, because it occupies the same space as the actors. Some of the effects are rough, and not every transformation works, but the hands-on quality gives the film an unpleasant texture. I’d sooner see an imperfect effect that has weight than a perfect one that seems to float above the scene.
There are moments when the film briefly remembers how frightening its premise could be. A figure caught in strange light, a face that has become unfamiliar or a shape held at a distance can suggest a force we don’t fully understand. The problem is that these images don’t consistently build towards anything emotionally inevitable. They interrupt the story, make an impression and disappear, leaving the dialogue to move the pieces around again.
Effects alone can’t carry that burden. A transformation is more disturbing when it tells us something about the person being transformed, and a violent death means more when the victim has been allowed a life beyond their function in the plot. The Morrigan has enough craft to make individual moments worth looking at, but not always enough connective tissue to make them stay with me.

When bad decisions become the real enemy
What finally took me out of the film wasn’t the supernatural material at all. It was the steady accumulation of decisions that seemed disconnected from experience, training or straightforward fear. Fiona is meant to be an intelligent specialist; Lily is angry, not incapable of thought; the adults around them have lived in the world long enough to recognise when something has become seriously dangerous. Yet the film needs them to keep wandering into situations that any reasonably alert person would question.
Horror doesn’t require clever people, and I wouldn’t want it to. Panic makes people inconsistent, grief makes people reckless, and arrogance can make even an expert miss the obvious. The difference is that a believable mistake reveals something about a character. An unbelievable mistake usually reveals something about the writer. When I can no longer connect an action to the person taking it, the suspense turns into a running argument with the screen.
By the later stages, I was no longer interested only in what the Morrigan intended to do next. I was wondering how many people would make it easier for her. That is not the response a film aiming for atmosphere and tragic inevitability wants to provoke. It’s possible to forgive a lot in modest horror, including awkward dialogue and some visible joins; it is harder to forgive the sense that everyone has been deprived of basic survival instincts for the sake of pacing.

The better film buried beneath this one
There is a version of The Morrigan that I would have liked considerably more, and I can see parts of it in what Eastwood has made. In that version Fiona’s research is implicated in the danger, Lily’s possession grows out of an anger that existed before the goddess arrived, and the island has enough communal history to make its silences meaningful. The Morrígan herself needn’t be explained into submission. She might be more frightening as a presence that reveals what people already believe, fear or have chosen to forget.
I didn’t hate the film, and I don’t think its good points deserve to be dismissed. Burrows and Flain give it a usable emotional centre, the other actors bring credibility, the landscape suits the material and the practical effects have some welcome roughness. But I finished it feeling disappointed rather than unsettled. The Morrigan excavates an ancient war goddess and then settles for a series of rather modern screenplay contrivances. The interesting film is somewhere underneath; the trouble is that the dig never quite reaches it.
Leave a Reply