
Two pilots crash on a hostile planet. Neither trusts the other. Somewhere along the way, a war story becomes an unlikely account of friendship, loss and family.
Spoiler warning: This article discusses the ending and major plot developments.
A planet made of rock, smoke and bad decisions
There is something immediately familiar about the alien landscapes of Enemy Mine. The skies are the wrong colour, the rocks look deliberately arranged, and everything appears to have been liberally sprayed with smoke just before somebody shouted action. I rather like that. It belongs to an age when filmmakers built entire worlds inside soundstages and then used lighting, matte paintings and a fair amount of nerve to persuade us that those worlds continued for thousands of miles beyond the camera.

Released in December 1985, Wolfgang Petersen’s film stars Dennis Quaid as human fighter pilot Willis E. Davidge and Louis Gossett Jr as Jeriba Shigan, a reptilian alien of the Drac species. Humanity and the Dracs are fighting over territory beyond Earth, although the opening wisely avoids drowning us in galactic politics. The important thing is that both species have fought long enough for hatred to become routine. They need very little encouragement to kill one another.

It looks at first like a space-war adventure shaped by the success of Star Wars: fighter squadrons, a huge orbital military base, glowing engines and enough celestial objects in the background to stock a small astronomy museum. Underneath all that machinery, however, sits a much more intimate film about two individuals who have been conditioned to think of each other as monsters.

As a viewer raised on elaborate miniatures, model kits and slightly unconvincing alien scenery, I find the design difficult to resist. That doesn’t mean every effect works. Some look wonderful, others reveal their painted backdrops rather too eagerly. But a film can look imperfect and still have a stronger reason for existing than a great many slicker productions.

It takes two idiots to start a war
Davidge begins as a fairly objectionable man. He is cocky, impatient and talented enough to be dangerous, but not nearly as wise as his confidence suggests. During a dogfight he breaks formation to chase a Drac fighter, shoots it down and wrecks his own craft in the process. His co-pilot Joey Wooster, played by Lance Kerwin, dies after the crash. Davidge finds himself stranded on the volcanic world Fyrine IV, and the pilot of the enemy craft has survived as well.

His immediate response is to hunt the Drac and finish the fight. Never mind that he has no working spacecraft, very few supplies and no understanding of the planet’s ecology. He has an enemy to kill, and apparently that is enough of a purpose for the afternoon. The film is quite good at making this stupidity seem consistent with the soldier we have already met.

The Drac is no more welcoming. Their first encounters involve threats, improvised weapons and a succession of misunderstandings. It takes meteor storms, dangerous local wildlife and the prospect of dying alone to persuade them that cooperation might be more useful than revenge. The landscape doesn’t care about military rank or the supposed superiority of either species.

Eventually they share shelter, food and knowledge, learning small pieces of each other’s language as they go. Davidge discovers that his companion is called Jeriba Shigan and begins calling the Drac ‘Jerry’. Partly it is a practical abbreviation and partly it is funny: the alien he was prepared to murder now has a name that sounds like somebody who might borrow your lawnmower.

One of the funniest moments arrives when Davidge’s elaborate effort to build shelter collapses almost immediately, sending Jerry into wheezing, reptilian laughter. It matters because it is difficult to maintain the notion that the other person is a faceless enemy when that person has just watched you make a complete fool of yourself.

Learning how to be stranded together
Their friendship develops through practical chores rather than a sudden moral revelation. They must find water, protect themselves against weather and understand the local animals before becoming their next meal. Davidge can improvise but frequently misjudges the environment. Jerry understands more about survival, though neither pilot is particularly enthusiastic about taking instructions from the other.

Fyrine IV is not simply a barren quarry with coloured lighting. Its cuca creatures, their durable shells and the enormous predator lurking beneath the surface establish the beginning of a functioning alien ecosystem. The giant sand-dwelling monster is perhaps a little too eager to demonstrate the dangers of the planet, but its presence gives the two castaways a threat that cannot be settled by declaring allegiance.

The enormous artificial skies and cavernous interior locations have the quality of a theatrical production staged on a particularly extravagant budget. Yet the sets also allow Quaid and Gossett to occupy the same real space. They can touch the rocks, fall in the dust and struggle through the weather, rather than merely reacting to objects added months later.

I find the gradual shift in their behaviour more persuasive than any sermon about tolerance would have been. They still argue, still irritate one another and remain unmistakably different. But they are learning which habits mean irritation, fear, kindness or humour. That is a more interesting form of understanding than discovering that an alien secretly behaves exactly like a human.

Watching the film again, what stands out is the domestic routine. The spaceship battles are over quite quickly; the conversations about food, shelter and the stupidity of one another’s customs have a far more lasting effect. Two enemies are slowly becoming the only familiar things on an unfamiliar planet.

Louis Gossett Jr does the difficult work
Dennis Quaid supplies the loud, irritable human energy that the early scenes require, but it is Louis Gossett Jr who makes the film believable. Jerry could easily have become an unfortunate collection of rubber scales and theatrical vocal effects. Instead, Gossett produces a fully formed personality from beneath one of the more demanding prosthetic constructions of the decade.

Jerry’s posture, small gestures, strange speech rhythms and extraordinary laugh all suggest a creature who possesses his own history long before Davidge arrives. Gossett makes him patient and exasperated, capable of genuine warmth and perfectly willing to be unpleasant when it is deserved. The performance never depends on turning the Drac into a conventionally appealing human substitute.

Gossett had already won an Oscar for An Officer and a Gentleman, and he took on a role that would conceal nearly every familiar tool an actor has. Preparations involved movement exercises and demanding make-up sessions, made more difficult by sensitive skin and troublesome contact lenses. Contemporary interviews also describe the peculiar gargling technique he used to lend Jerry a distinctive voice.

A lesser performance might have been swallowed by the design. Gossett somehow makes the prosthetics expressive. Even when the face cannot move like a human face, the eyes, head and body convey exactly what Jerry is thinking. That is the film’s largest technical and emotional achievement.

Latex, painted skies and other stubbornly physical things
The creature design overseen by Chris Walas went through extensive changes when Petersen took over the production. Early concepts were discarded, and the final Drac appearance settled into its textured, heavy-lidded, reptilian form. The detail is elaborate enough to suggest an entire species without preventing Gossett from giving a recognisable performance.

There are moments when the mask looks remarkable and moments when one can see the limits of the material. I don’t find those shortcomings fatal. As someone who has spent years looking at the construction of images, I’m more interested in what the artists were trying to achieve than in whether every seam has been digitally erased.

The same applies to the spaceships and creatures. Miniatures, sculpted props, puppets and matte paintings make this a film full of actual objects. The effects are not uniformly superior to modern digital work, and some are decidedly awkward, but they possess weight, texture and the signs of having been made by human hands. That quality has become part of the film’s appeal rather than simply an embarrassment we have to overlook.

The Talman, Mickey Mouse and the problem with certainty
Eventually Jerry teaches Davidge something about Drac religion and heritage. Jerry carries the Talman, a sacred text containing teachings associated with the philosopher Shizumaat. Davidge’s initial response is to dismiss much of it, which is exactly what we should expect from somebody who takes his own cultural assumptions as the natural order of the universe.

Their exchanges about belief and Mickey Mouse are funny because they expose how differently people organise what matters. An important name can represent a spiritual tradition to one person and a meaningless collection of sounds to another. Davidge does not have to become a Drac believer for the film to make its point. He simply has to recognise that Jerry’s beliefs deserve to be understood before being mocked.

Jerry also remembers an immense succession of ancestors through the Jeriba family lineage. Davidge, by contrast, can name relatively little of his own history. There is a lovely irony in that: humanity has learned to cross interstellar distances, yet this particular human struggles to remember the names of people who made his life possible. Jerry has no working spaceship, but carries generations of family history in his head.

A friendship made from rather ordinary things
The most convincing passages are rarely the most expensive. Davidge and Jerry eat, argue, make jokes and sit together. Their different anatomies and rituals remain strange to one another, but the longer they share the same home the harder it becomes to reduce either individual to a caricature of an entire species.

I like that neither becomes wholly agreeable. Friendship is not presented as a magical cure for irritating habits. The characters continue to disagree, sometimes over trivial matters, and the film allows genuine irritation to coexist with affection. Their understanding feels earned because it comes with the small frictions of living together.

The sets help create that sense of shared domestic space. At first the planet is an obstacle course; later it becomes an environment with familiar routes, preferred corners and a makeshift household. The alien landscape has not become safer, but it has become known.

That is also where the film begins to outgrow its action-adventure framing. A story about who wins the war becomes a story about who prepares the food, who learns the language and who remembers what matters to the other. There is something quietly radical about making this kind of routine the centre of an expensive science-fiction film.

For all my affection for the spacecraft, I could happily sacrifice some of their screen time for a few more scenes of these two talking. I suspect that is not the reaction the studio originally hoped for when it spent an extraordinary amount of money building an alien planet.

The film that had to be made twice
The production history explains some of the finished film’s oddness. Barry B. Longyear’s 1979 novella was adapted by screenwriter Edward Khmara, with Richard Loncraine originally directing. Filming began in Iceland in April 1984, partly because the volcanic landscape appeared suitable for an alien world. The difficult location, escalating costs and disagreements about the footage led to Loncraine’s dismissal.

Wolfgang Petersen, already celebrated for Das Boot and working after The NeverEnding Story, agreed to take over on the condition that the production begin again with a different approach. Sets and designs were reworked, the principal studio work moved to Bavaria Studios in Munich, and Lanzarote supplied the revised exterior landscapes. That is not a minor course correction. It is effectively making the same film twice.

The eventual production occupied nine of Bavaria’s eleven soundstages. Its volcanic landscapes involved elaborate constructions and painted skies, with atmospheric smoke sometimes being used so heavily that crew members complained about it. The film also required internationally coordinated miniature and optical effects work, including contributions from Industrial Light & Magic.

By release, the combined production and associated costs were reported at more than US$40 million, an astonishing sum for a story that spends so much time with two actors in a cave. The film’s uneven rhythm makes more sense when placed alongside the many discarded designs, rewritten sequences and compromises that preceded it.

Still, I find it remarkable that the central relationship emerged intact. In a production where nearly everything could change, the thing that continued to work was the simplest element: two performers gradually persuading us that their characters had begun to care for each other.

Barry B. Longyear wrote a more uncomfortable ending
Longyear’s original novella, first published in Isaac Asimov’s Science Fiction Magazine in September 1979, went on to win the Hugo and Nebula awards for best novella. Its central relationship is immediately recognisable, but the book is less interested in turning its ideas into an action spectacle.

In the source story, prejudice does not conveniently disappear once Davidge has learned to love Jerry and care for Zammis. After Jerry’s death, Davidge and the child must contend with societies that remain suspicious of their unusual relationship. The resistance is institutional and cultural rather than reducible to a handful of easily defeated criminals.

That makes the novella, for me, the more uncomfortable work. Private friendship can change two people, but it cannot immediately rewrite the habits of a whole society. The film retains the promise surrounding the Jeriba lineage while moving much of the final conflict into a conventional rescue adventure. I understand the decision commercially; I am less convinced it improved the story.
The title itself gains a slightly different flavour once the film’s illegal mining operation arrives. The literal mine is a Hollywood addition, while the original title’s more interesting meaning concerns the enemy each character has been taught to perceive. The film eventually finds its way back to that idea, but it takes a fairly noisy detour.
The child neither of them planned to raise
The plot’s most unexpected turn comes when Jerry announces that a child is on the way. Dracs reproduce differently from humans, and Jerry’s pregnancy leaves Davidge with a great deal to understand very quickly. He has barely adjusted to sharing a home with one Drac; now there is the possibility of raising another.

The delivery is difficult. Jerry dies, but Davidge saves the infant, Zammis, and is left to honour the promise he made to his friend. The story shifts again, from friendship to grief and then to the everyday responsibilities of bringing up a child.

I like that the film doesn’t insist on a grand speech about fatherhood. Davidge simply has to feed, protect, teach and comfort a small creature whose appearance would once have frightened or repulsed him. The man who set out to kill a Drac now devotes his life to keeping one alive.

Bumper Robinson gives the older Zammis a curious, affectionate personality. Their conversations, small lessons and games have a pleasantly ordinary quality. The difference in their hands becomes a point of interest rather than an argument about which species is better.

Zammis does not instinctively understand the war or why humans might present a danger. Davidge has to explain that people who look like him aren’t necessarily people the child should trust. It is one of the film’s more affecting reversals, and far removed from the boastful pilot we met at the beginning.
Then Hollywood remembers that it needs a villain
The last act introduces human scavengers who exploit captured Dracs as forced labour in an illegal mining operation. Davidge understands their danger, but Zammis is eventually captured, sending the film towards a rescue sequence that feels much more familiar than its preceding domestic drama.

Brion James plays the scavenger leader Stubbs with the practiced unpleasantness that made him such a dependable screen villain. He is effective, though the character is not especially complicated. The miners exist largely to personify the wider prejudice Davidge has moved beyond, and to give the action sequence someone concrete to fight.

The rescue involves industrial structures, weapons, narrow escapes and a return to the military society Davidge once served. Some of the action is entertaining, but the film’s priorities become less clear. The story had spent much of its running time demonstrating the difficulty of understanding another person, only to decide that the resolution required more people shooting at one another.

The narrative also becomes noticeably rushed. Davidge’s recovery, his strained reunion with other humans and the effort to return to Zammis all pass more quickly than they should. I can accept the plot mechanics, but I miss the quieter confidence the film showed while Jerry and Davidge were simply learning to live together.

It is the weakest portion for me, not because action is inherently inappropriate, but because the emotional conflict is so much more interesting than the physical one. The miners are easily replaceable villains; Jerry and Zammis are what give the film its identity.

Even so, the rescue brings Davidge to a meaningful decision. He no longer sees the child as an alien he happens to protect, but as family. That is the important victory, whatever the final explosion is trying to tell us.

Maurice Jarre, the box-office disaster and one last family name
Maurice Jarre’s score adds another unmistakably 1980s texture. The music blends sweeping orchestral feeling with electronic colours that suit an imaginary world built of matte paintings and stage smoke. It can be rather insistent about the emotions it wants us to feel, but the themes associated with companionship and separation have genuine warmth.

When Enemy Mine opened in American cinemas on 20 December 1985, its commercial performance was grim. Domestic takings of roughly US$12.3 million were nowhere near the vast production expenditure. Reviews were mixed, with some critics finding it sentimental, visually awkward and overloaded with expensive scenery.

It is not difficult to understand those criticisms. The effects are inconsistent, the final act is too conventional, and the narration sometimes explains events that the actors have already conveyed perfectly well. This is not a flawless masterpiece hiding behind bad box-office receipts.

Yet it is exactly the kind of film that could develop another life through VHS rentals and television screenings. In those days I did not always know whether a film had been a hit. Sometimes it simply appeared on a shelf, its artwork looked interesting, and that was enough to warrant an evening with it. Films that failed theatrically could still become part of someone’s personal history.
The final ceremony returns the story to what matters. Davidge takes Zammis to the Drac homeworld and fulfils his promise to Jerry by recounting the Jeriba lineage before the holy council. We learn that, in the future, Willis Davidge himself will be remembered within that family history. The man who could barely name his own ancestors becomes part of a tradition older and richer than he could once have imagined.
That last detail moves me far more than the mining rescue. It isn’t a sudden declaration that the galaxy has become enlightened. It is something quieter and more lasting: one man is remembered by a family to which he was never biologically related, because of what he chose to do.
At its best Enemy Mine is a film about dismantling assumptions one awkward conversation at a time. I could lose some of the gunfire, and I wouldn’t mind a little less narration, but I wouldn’t want the rough-edged planet redesigned into something immaculate. The latex, miniatures, painted skies and extraordinary performance underneath it all belong to the film. So does that ending. My rating: 4/5.
Further reading and production sources
The film credits and original novella publication are documented in the AFI catalogue. Contemporary reporting on the rebuilt production appears in the Los Angeles Times. Additional production detail, including the special-effects history, is discussed in the FictionMachine retrospective and in an interview with make-up artist Chris Walas.
Leave a Reply