, , ,

The Trail (2024) Review: An Alien in the Alps, and the Trouble with Silence

There is something faintly suspicious about a film that begins with someone hiking alone. In the cinema, nobody seems to put on a rucksack and walk into the mountains simply because the weather looks decent and they fancy a bit of exercise. The journey is usually a metaphor, a test, or a spectacularly poor decision made in expensive outdoor clothing. In The Trail (2024), it is all three, with an extraterrestrial complication thrown in for good measure.

Stefan Müller’s Austrian science-fiction horror film follows Anna, played by Sophia Grabner, into the Alps as she attempts to live with a trauma that has already altered her life. The premise suggests a fairly straightforward survival thriller: solitary hiker, beautiful wilderness, something alien waiting among the trees. What Müller gives us instead is an unusually subdued film about fear, exposure and the difficulty of putting one foot in front of the other when the thing you are carrying weighs rather more than your backpack.

I found myself responding to it in two ways. I liked its refusal to behave like a conventional alien-encounter film, and I liked the way the mountains seemed to exist independently of Anna’s problems. But I also spent stretches wondering whether the film was building suspense or merely asking me to admire another patch of woodland. That tension between an interesting artistic choice and a slightly exhausting viewing experience is where The Trail sits for me.

A mountain path with very little company

This is a modest production, and it makes a virtue of keeping its world small. Müller, who directed the film and co-wrote it with Martin Kroissenbrunner, does not give us military briefings, scientists with urgent diagrams or the reassuring chatter of people who know exactly what kind of film they are in. We get Anna, the path, the woods, and the sense that something is slightly wrong before there is anything concrete to identify. The landscape does most of the early work, and for long stretches the camera seems content to let it.

The Austrian setting gives the film a character that would be difficult to manufacture on a soundstage. The mountains look magnificent, but the beauty is entirely indifferent. There is no suggestion that they will look after Anna just because she has come here seeking some sort of release. A city can make you feel lonely because you are surrounded by people who do not know you; a mountain can make you feel lonely because it has never had the slightest interest in knowing you at all.

Anna, wearing hiking gear, looks apprehensively ahead in warm afternoon light.
Anna scans the landscape, uneasy despite the sunlight. Film still: LOOM / Fly Oli, via IMDb.

That indifference becomes a useful dramatic device. Anna has travelled into the open to deal with something painfully private, yet the wide views do not make her troubles smaller in any comforting sense. They make her look exposed. I liked that contradiction: the very place she has chosen for solitude offers fewer distractions, fewer people and, eventually, fewer places to hide.

Anna, and everything she cannot say

Grabner carries almost the entire film through movement and expression rather than dialogue. Anna walks, listens, hesitates and looks around her with the wary concentration of someone who has not felt properly safe for a long time. That restraint makes sense within the story. The official Austrian synopsis describes physical wounds that have deprived Anna of speech, alongside the inner fears she has travelled here to confront. Her silence is therefore not simply the director showing off his fondness for minimalism; it is also part of what has happened to her.

It is a demanding part because the film asks us to interpret small gestures that more conventional screenplays might spell out in conversation. Sometimes the camera stays with Grabner’s face long enough for a reaction to become meaningful, and she holds those moments well. Anna does not feel like a ready-made action heroine waiting for an excuse to become one. She feels like somebody already having a difficult time before the science-fiction element arrives to make matters distinctly worse.

There is a recognisable impulse behind her hike. People turn to practical tasks when an emotional problem refuses to stay within sensible boundaries. We go away, rearrange the house, start running, clear the cupboards or develop a sudden interest in walking equipment. The body is given something specific to do while the mind continues its less orderly business. Anna’s journey has that quality, although the film is careful not to pretend that putting miles behind you necessarily means leaving anything else behind.

Other people, half-seen through the damage

The supporting cast is small, but the connections matter. Julia Foidl plays Sophia, with Corinna Pumm and Oliver Haas credited as Sophia’s parents, while Stefan Schnuderl plays a figure linked to Anna’s past. These roles do not expand into the kind of ensemble story that would interrupt Anna’s solitude for very long. Instead, they suggest a wider history and an emotional aftermath that cannot be tidied away simply by changing the scenery.

That is one of the film’s better instincts, even if I sometimes wanted a little more information at the right moment. Withholding a backstory can make a character mysterious, but it can also leave the audience at arm’s length. The Trail occasionally asks us to feel the full weight of Anna’s distress before it has given that distress enough shape. The difference between productive ambiguity and unnecessary obscurity is not always clear, and the film spends quite a while balancing on it.

Anna in a purple hiking jacket pauses anxiously in a dim woodland.
With so little dialogue, Anna’s reactions have to carry much of the tension. Film still: LOOM / Fly Oli, via IMDb.

Still, I preferred this fractured approach to the alternative of having someone explain Anna’s past in a conveniently timed speech. The film treats memory as something that does not always arrive in an orderly sequence, and that feels right for the material. It also makes the ordinary prospect of encountering another person on a remote trail surprisingly uncertain. In a busier film, a passing hiker would barely register; here, any human presence has the potential to be help, danger or another reminder of something Anna has not managed to escape.

An alien has no business being in this landscape

The extraterrestrial intrusion works because the film has spent so long establishing a world that appears entirely familiar. We know what forests, rocks, low clouds and hiking paths are supposed to look like. The sight of an impossible object among them creates a more peculiar disturbance than it would in a laboratory or on a spacecraft, where the audience has already agreed that impossible technology belongs. There is a satisfying wrongness to the science fiction here, as though two genres have wandered into the same clearing and neither is especially pleased about it.

Müller is sensible enough not to turn the encounter into an effects demonstration. The threat is frightening less because we are supplied with an elaborate mythology than because Anna has so little control over the situation. Whatever has come into the mountains, it has intruded upon a journey that was already difficult. The film keeps asking whether fear originates inside her, outside her or somewhere uncomfortable between the two, without insisting that one answer must cancel the other.

Promotional artwork shows a tiny backpacker facing a huge circular metallic structure in a rocky landscape.
A human figure dwarfed by an impossible structure: the film’s Alpine science-fiction premise in one image. Promotional artwork: LOOM / Fly Oli.

I am a little wary of the modern horror habit of making every monster stand for unresolved trauma. Used carelessly, it can feel as though a perfectly serviceable creature has been asked to work part-time as a therapist. The Trail comes close to that territory, but its physical setting helps. Anna still has to move through real space, deal with the terrain and respond to something that can hurt her. The idea may be symbolic, but the immediate problem remains satisfyingly unpleasant.

The sound of waiting for something to happen

Silence is the film’s most distinctive tool. When characters are not constantly talking, the audience begins to take ordinary sounds rather seriously: feet on loose ground, a rustle in the trees, a breath held slightly too long. Sound becomes a map of the places Anna cannot see. What begins as quiet gradually acquires the uncomfortable quality of a room in which someone else might be present, even when no one is visible.

I liked how that changes the experience of watching the film. With very little dialogue to guide us, we have to pay attention to posture, distance, direction and the timing of a glance. It is the sort of filmmaking that can make a tiny movement feel significant. At its best, The Trail creates a mood through exactly those small things, trusting us to sit with Anna rather than handing us a running commentary on what she ought to be feeling.

The Trail (2024) — international trailer, presented by BritFlicks. The footage gives a sense of the film’s Alpine setting and its collision with science fiction.

The difficulty, unfortunately, is that the same technique can also drain a scene of momentum. There is a point at which holding a shot no longer makes me more apprehensive; it simply makes me conscious of how long the shot has been held. That happened more than once. The film understands that patience is essential to suspense, but does not always distinguish waiting for something from waiting around.

When a slow burn forgets to turn up the heat

The Trail is a slow film, and I do not say that as an automatic criticism. Some of my favourite genre films take time to establish a place and then allow the smallest disruption to become alarming. The question is whether the rhythm continues to change as the story moves forward. Here, the difference between anticipation and delay occasionally becomes a little too fine for my liking, and the mountain scenery is asked to cover a fair amount of dramatic dead air.

There were stretches when I admired Müller’s confidence in the material and others when I wanted to ask, very politely, whether we were still doing the story. The problem is not that nothing happens. It is that the film sometimes returns to the same emotional and visual register without enough variation to sharpen it. Its restraint is genuine, but restraint alone is not a substitute for shape. A slightly tighter edit might have kept the atmosphere while making the mounting danger feel more urgent.

The alien mythology is similarly spare. I did not need an origin story, an explanation of its biology or the inevitable scene in which somebody solemnly tells us humanity is not ready for the truth. But a few more concrete details about the danger might have made the final movement more satisfying. The film is strongest when the unknown feels threatening; it is weaker when the unknown begins to resemble information that the storytelling simply has not bothered to supply.

Why I still have time for a film like this

For all that, I find it difficult to dismiss The Trail. It has an identity, and that is more than can be said for quite a few larger horror films that arrive with immaculate lighting, interchangeable characters and a monster designed by committee. This one is uneven in more personal ways. Its limits are visible, but so is the attempt to make something from them: a woman, a stretch of wilderness, very little dialogue and an impossible presence that makes everything she has carried into the mountains harder to contain.

I also appreciated that the film does not pretend confronting fear is the same thing as resolving it. There is no convincing reason that one terrifying encounter should neatly cure years of hurt. Anna’s journey is an ordeal, not a self-help retreat, and the setting is too indifferent to offer the usual reassuring lesson. The mountains do not explain themselves, and they do not owe anyone a revelation. They simply remain where they are, beautiful and inconvenient, while human beings try to make sense of what has happened to them.

The Trail — earlier official trailer from LOOM, showing the film’s quieter, more ominous approach to Alpine horror.

In the end, I liked The Trail more as an experience than as a fully satisfying story. Grabner’s performance, the Alpine photography and the sense of something profoundly out of place stayed with me. So did the frustrating pauses, the distant emotional information and the feeling that the film might have been stronger with a little less walking and a little more variation in its pace. It is an imperfect, stubborn little piece of Austrian genre cinema, but at least its strangeness feels like its own.

Not every monster needs to be explained. Not every mountain walk needs to change your life, either. Sometimes the most unsettling thing about going somewhere remote is discovering that what you brought with you is still there when the trail ends.

Film details: LOOM’s official production page and film.at. Film stills and promotional artwork reproduced for review and commentary; rights remain with their respective owners.



The Weekend Transmission

One thing watched. One thing heard. One thing found in the attic — plus new essays, rediscovered music and occasional recommendations, delivered by email rather than left to an algorithm.

Leave a Reply